Three weeks. That’s how far out Led Zeppelin was from kicking off an American tour, their first in the U.S. since 1977, when everything stopped. On September 25, 1980, John Bonham was found dead at Jimmy Page’s house after a day of heavy drinking, just 32 years old. Rehearsals ended. The tour never happened. And on December 4, 1980, the three surviving members released a two sentence statement that still gives fans chills: “We wish it to be known that the loss of our dear friend and the deep respect we have for his family, together with the sense of undivided harmony felt by ourselves and our manager, have led us to decide that we could not continue as we were.”
No auditions. No replacement drummer quietly slotted in for a farewell cash grab. Led Zeppelin just ended, and I think that was exactly right, for a reason people still argue about: Bonham wasn’t a great drummer in Led Zeppelin, he was the reason Led Zeppelin sounded like Led Zeppelin. That behind the beat swing on “Fool in the Rain,” the sheer weight of “When the Levee Breaks,” none of it survives a substitution. Even Jason Bonham, sitting behind his father’s kit for the one off 2007 reunion at London’s O2 Arena, was the closest anyone’s ever come and still not quite it. Zeppelin knew the difference between losing a member and losing the engine.
Compare that to the same year. Bon Scott, AC/DC’s original frontman, died February 19, 1980. The band seriously considered quitting, then didn’t. They hired Brian Johnson, and five months later Back in Black became the second best selling album in history. This week we get the receipts on how well that bet kept paying off: The Razor’s Edge, home of “Thunderstruck,” dropped September 24, 1990, and Ballbreaker followed in late September 1995. A frontman, it turns out, can be mourned and honored while the band plays on. AC/DC is proof.
Metallica faced a version of the same test. Bassist Cliff Burton died on September 27, 1986, when the band’s tour bus skidded off a Swedish road and flipped, he was 24. Metallica grieved, hired Jason Newsted, and kept building toward the empire they are today. Nobody seriously argues Metallica should have quit after Master of Puppets. A rhythm section player, however brilliant, isn’t always the whole architecture.
That’s the real debate hiding inside this week’s dates: not every loss is the same size. A voice can be replaced with respect. A low end can be rebuilt. But when the thing that made a band’s sound impossible to copy walks out the door for good, sometimes the only honest move left is to stop.
The rest of the week backs up how much was riding on lineups staying intact in the first place. Black Sabbath, all four original members, dropped Vol. 4 on September 22, 1972, doubling down on doom with “Snowblind.” Mötley Crüe’s Shout at the Devil hit shelves September 23, 1983, turning a club act into an arena band overnight. Megadeth’s Rust in Peace, released September 24, 1990, is still the argument-ender for best thrash album ever, made by a band whose classic lineup barely held together long enough to record it. And Cheap Trick’s Dream Police, out September 21, 1979, became the band’s highest charting studio album, peaking at No. 6, proof arena rock didn’t need tragedy or turmoil to hit big.
So here’s the question for the comments. Did Led Zeppelin make the right call by walking away in 1980, or did the world lose two more decades of music it should have gotten? And if Jason Bonham can get close enough for one night at the O2, why not a real tour?
Leave a Reply